A FAMILIAR MEME. A NEW CONTEXT.

What Are You in For? (I Killed a Man)

What this meme means

A comic of two inmates: a big guy confesses to murder, then asks his neighbor what he did. The answer is a minor or absurd crime that sounds worse in context. It peaked in popularity in 2017.

Add your caption

The editor opens with this picture. You can download the finished meme as a PNG.

Report this meme

The comic and its structure

The meme is based on a brief comic scene: two inmates sit in a cell, and one of them, large and bald, confesses to killing someone. The other asks what he himself is in for and answers with something trivial. The format is designed as three panels: the confession, the question, and the answer with an unexpected twist, in which the second man's crime turns out to be more disturbing than the first man's confession.

The accompanying image shows a single frame from this scene: on the left sits a thin inmate wearing glasses, and on the right a heavyset bald man slumped on a bench. Orange jumpsuits, gray walls with rectangular panel outlines, and a soft cartoon style all match the genre. However, this image does not show the three panels or the dialogue text, so the description of the structure relies on the catalog's text rather than on the picture. This discrepancy is worth noting.

Origins in 2009

The earliest publication found dates to July 30, 2009. It was posted by a gaming website, where the comic was titled "Xbox Killer." In the original version, the large inmate talks about a serious crime, and his cellmate replies that he bought an Xbox 360 just to watch it die. The large inmate scoots to the other side of the cell. The lines are deliberately over the top, and the joke is built on the sharp drop from a grim confession to a mundane absurdity.

Authorship remains unclear. A name is mentioned in the caption, but the author cannot be established. The meme dates to 2009.

Remixes from 2010 to 2013

In 2010, a member of an esports forum made a remix in which the small inmate claims to be the director of a well-known shocking video. This was one of the first examples of the comic being rewritten for absurd and outright crude lines. In 2012, a blank template appeared on a bodybuilding forum, and in January 2013 it reached the imageboard 4chan, where users rewrote the lines en masse.

This is how the meme's key mechanism took shape: the structure of the scene stays the same while the content of the lines changes. The comic turns into an empty frame into which any twist can be written, which is why it has gone through several waves of popularity without losing its recognizability.

Peak popularity in 2017

The main surge came in 2017. On June 30, a Reddit user posted the comic in a meme-themed subreddit with a caption saying he'd laughed at a meme from another platform. Over three months, the post gathered about 16,000 points. On October 8 of the same year, a version poking fun at swearing on a Christian Minecraft server appeared, and within a day it collected more than 830 points on a "dank memes" subreddit.

In the Russian-speaking internet, the scenario is more often called "What are you in for?" The name stuck as a translation of the opening line, and it preserves the main idea: the confession sets a high bar, and the answer knocks it down.

The joke's premise

The meme's mechanic is based on build-up and a sudden drop. A confession to a serious crime sets a high bar, and the cellmate's answer sharply lowers it to a mundane or absurd triviality. By this world's standards, the minor offense looks worse than murder. It's precisely this inverted scale that makes the joke recognizable and lets it be applied to any topic.

The image belongs to the genre of drawn comics, the characters are fictional, and the scene is not connected to any real people. The meme is therefore not a case of mocking private individuals or real crimes. It works as a purely absurdist construction, and its grim setting serves only as a backdrop for the unexpected twist.